Are Mesh Networks Reliable?
A practical look at how reliable a mesh network really is out in the field, its limitations, and where it fits as an additional layer of communication.
For most groups using Nelos, the answer is no - at least not to start with. A repeater is an optional device you add later, when you actually need to cover a wider area.
In Nelos, each person's radio talks directly to the others in range. A normal companion radio - the handheld paired to your phone - doesn't relay messages for other people's devices. Relaying is the job of a repeater: a device fixed in a good position, no phone, no messaging, just forwarding messages and location between other devices. Some compatible radios and trackers can also be switched to a Companion Repeater mode that relays for nearby devices, on supported frequencies and at the cost of more battery.
For a group of a few people travelling together - the same route, the same small campsite, occasionally spreading a few hundred metres apart - the handhelds usually reach each other directly with nothing extra. In that case, buying and carrying a repeater is just dead weight. Start with the right number of handhelds for the number of people, and see whether there's actually a problem before adding one.
A repeater is worth it in a few specific situations:
A repeater is not a general way to boost range. It only helps if it's in a position where both sides that need linking can "see" it. Some cases where a repeater doesn't help:
A spare compatible handheld, switched to Companion Repeater mode on a frequency that supports it and placed temporarily on a car roof or hung from a high branch, can act as a temporary repeater for an outing. This is a light way to test whether an anchor point helps.
A dedicated repeater usually has a bigger battery or a solar panel, a weatherproof case, and a mount for fixed installation - suited to a long-term spot. See the repeaters section of the devices guide.
There's no "a repeater boosts range X times" formula - the result depends entirely on the specific terrain. A few general principles:
The field note on a first mountainside repeater deployment is a concrete example - not proof that every installation gives the same result.
Start without a repeater. Add one when you have a fixed point to take advantage of and a wide area or a piece of blocking terrain to cover. Don't expect it to be a general range boost, and don't trust any specific range figure. The guides Are Mesh Networks Reliable? and Camping Without Cell Service say more about how a network like this behaves in practice.
Nelos connects your phone to a LoRa device over Bluetooth and handles the mesh for you — just message your group and watch the map.